Help with recording lossless gameplay gifs (OBS)

[Filler]

Hey everyone!

I've been using OBS to record gameplay losslessy for gifs whenever I'm too lazy for videos. But ever since recently, it either was recording only a black screen, or it looked like a jpeg.

Here's a comparison gif of a screenshot and how OBS looks. (OBS is the brighter, washed out one)



Here's my settings if you wanted to see them.