Rapture! The Game. A new sidescroller coming soon.

[puggsoy]

I'd have to agree with Phaze, that second one doesn't in any way look like an improvement. I think I get the feel you're trying to give, it does look less "Photoshoppy", but I'd rather have that than a weird grainy picture that's uncomfortable to look at. Plus it makes the screen look out of place, since it's the only part which isn't grainy.