07-26-2011, 04:22 AM
That's true - And I agree that the first sprite could have colours reduced, and I believe that at the end there it was a good state.
But there's no reason to start removing colours to the point where it lacks details such as shading. Which I'm not saying your last edit lacks, but it's more a case of his has bolder detail that is more readable to my eye - perhaps this is increased to me personally because of my lack of colour vision in one eye, but that's just my opinion.
You've also changed the colours by your form of shading on certain areas such as the feet, and also removed the shading from his body. The shield also lacks any real shape.
But there's no reason to start removing colours to the point where it lacks details such as shading. Which I'm not saying your last edit lacks, but it's more a case of his has bolder detail that is more readable to my eye - perhaps this is increased to me personally because of my lack of colour vision in one eye, but that's just my opinion.
You've also changed the colours by your form of shading on certain areas such as the feet, and also removed the shading from his body. The shield also lacks any real shape.